Degree of Freedom

an adventure in online learning

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Twitter
  • HOME
  • CRITICAL THINKING
    • Critical Thinking Essentials
    • High-Leverage Critical Thinking Teaching Practices
      • Fulfilling the Promise of Critical Thinking Education
      • What Are High-Leverage Critical Thinking Practices?
      • The 8 High-Leverage Critical Thinking Teaching Practices
    • LogicCheck
    • Critical Voter
    • Critical Thinking – Writing and Interviews
  • MOOCS
    • The One Year BA
    • MOOCS Essentials
    • MOOCS – Writing and Interviews
    • Degree of Freedom Podcast
  • TEACHING AND EDUCATION
    • Remote Teaching Resources
    • Online Course – Assessment
    • Teaching and Education – Writing and Interviews
    • Podcast – New Books in Education
  • ABOUT/NEWS
    • About the Author
    • Interviews/Speaking Engagements
    • In the News
    • Published Writing
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Self Curation

September 10, 2013 By DegreeofFreedom in Filed Under: Degree of Freedom Project, Independent Learners

Last month, I talked about an Existentialism class offered by Saylor.org that is built from free material (iTunes U lectures, public domain readings, etc.) organized by a guiding hand into a course that can be described as curated, rather than produced and packaged like your standard MOOC.

And because of the dearth of new MOOC classes offered over the summer (and my own need for additional intermediate and advanced philosophy courses for my One Year Philosophy BA), I decided to try my own hand at course curation on a developing topic of interest:  Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason.

The starting material for this project was the curriculum, reading and assignment list associated with a Massachusetts Institute of Technology course on the subject available for free via MIT’s Open Courseware Initiative.  In addition to providing a book list organized into weekly reading assignments, MIT’s Open Courseware also included the professor’s original notes from each lecture.

Unfortunately, the 2-3 pages of lecture notes associated with each class didn’t satisfy my need for a guided presentation through what’s turned out to be pretty challenging material.  And so I added a series of iTunes U lectures on the Critique provided by Oxford professor Dan Robinson to my curation list, a fortunate choice given that Professor Robinson is probably the most able lecturer I’ve encountered during my year of extreme learning.

So like that Saylor Existentialism class, I’m making use of free, publically available material to construct a course, rather than waiting around for a university to decide to produce a MOOC on this subject.  But unlike the offerings by Saylor, the guiding hand for putting this material together is that of a student trying to learn the subject for the first time, rather than a professor familiar with both the topic and where to find the best readings, lectures and other resources needed to create the equivalent of a college class.

In a way, this makes the construction of a course part of the learning process, even if doing it yourself presents its own set of challenges.

For instance, the MIT reading list includes the extremely useful Guidebook to Kant which provides a walkthrough of themes and issues encountered in the Critique that pretty much follows the structure of the Critique itself.  This has proved vital as I try to match up readings from the Guide, readings from the original course material, MIT lecture notes and Oxford lectures into something approaching a coherent whole.

But a second book on problems raised by the Critique is proving to be somewhat disorienting absent lecture or discussion opportunities where those problems can be put into context. And so I am finding myself substituting this suggested reading with alternative material from some of the same sources Saylor has been using in their curated philosophy courses (notably the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and popular philosophy blogs Philosophy Bites and the Partially Examined Life).

This particular project is likely to finish towards the end of September (i.e., the end of my “Junior Year”), although I’m giving myself the leeway to let it spill over into October if necessary.  And while I still prefer more of a guiding hand through my courses, this experiment seems worth repeating during “Senior Year” (especially if I can’t find a formal course on the philosophy of Pragmatism which I feel compelled to include in my final degree lineup).

Given that curated courses don’t seem to attract the kind of numbers as even lesser known MOOCs (it looks like less than a hundred other students will have taken that Saylor Existentialism class for instance), self-curation is not likely to emerge as a mainstream learning strategy absent someone developing more formal rules of the road for pursuing such an option.

That said, it’s worth noting that the material needed to pursue this learning alternative is out there and available for free.  And given the growing popularity of Open everything, who can tell where access to this scope and quality of material might lead in the years to come?

Share this post:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print

Comments

  1. Bel says

    August 23, 2016 at 2:15 pm

    Existentialism, learning and development and curation – the most interesting article I have read in a long time with all my favourite topics. Thank you for sharing.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Recent
  • Comments
  • Tags

Sign up for the Degree of Freedom Newsletter

Recent Posts

  • Event and Interview
  • How to Win an Argument
  • Ethics Bowl
  • Interview with Michael Horn and Vox
  • Channeling Doubt Productively
  • Leveraging the Power of Doubt
  • A Juicy Topic – Critical Thinking

Latest Published Writing

Remote Learning Begs the Question:  Must Lectures Be So Long? (EdSurge – May 25, 2020)

It’s Time to Get Serious About Teaching Critical Thinking (Inside Higher Education – March 2, 2020)

Why the ‘Best’ Ideas in Education Technology and Reform Don’t Win (EdSurge – February 5, 2020)

Is Education Entering an “Age of Alternatives”? (EdSurge – March 2, 2019)

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,063 other subscribers

Copyright © 2025 · Degree of Freedom. All Rights Reserved.

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.